Texas Criminal Defense Lawyers

Texas Criminal Defense Lawyers help you fight criminal charges in Texas courts.

Call Us Free Legal Consultation

888-205-9314

  • Home
  • Texas Criminal Laws & Penalties
  • Texas Criminal Procedures
    • Assault
    • Burglary
    • Criminal Mischief / Arson
    • Disorderly Conduct
    • Domestic Assault Laws
    • Drug Delivery
    • Drug Possession
    • Drug Possession – Cocaine
    • Drug Possession – Heroin
    • Drug Possession – Marijuana
    • Drug Possession – Methamphetamine
    • DWI Laws
    • DWI – 2nd Offense
    • DWI – Occupational License
    • Embezzlement
    • Failure to Appear / Bail Jumping
    • Fraud
    • Harassment
    • Hit and Run
    • Robbery
    • Reckless Driving
    • Suspended License
    • Sex Offenses
    • Theft
    • Violation of a Protective Order
    • Weapons Charges
  • About the Attorneys
    • Disclaimer / Privacy
  • Blog

MADD Pushes for Alcohol Sensing Systems in All Cars

November 16, 2010

The anti-drunk driving organization, MADD, is pushing for $60 million in federal funding to research technology that would prevent any car from starting if the driver is intoxicated. These goal of such systems standard in all cars, and possibly set at the threshold level of “any” alcohol, are prompting concerns that MADD has veered into being a neo-prohibitionist organization.

This article from the Dallas Morning News outlines the agenda for MADD, which includes a push for this research, as well as continuing lobbying efforts to require an ignition interlock device installed in any driver’s vehicle after a DWI conviction. Thought interlock devices are mandatory for 1st offense drunk driving charges in Arizona, Illinois, and other states.

St. Patrick's Day Ride Along 3
Creative Commons License photo credit: JSmith Photo

However, under Texas law, the devices are only mandatory on first offense convictions if the driver recorded a BAC level or .15% or higher, or nearly twice the legal limit of alcohol in the bloodstream. Interlock requirements are typically coupled with a Texas Occupational Licence.

The article also notes recent criticism of MADD from Charity Navigator and the American Institute of Philanthropy, which rated the organization as having poorly allocated its charitable funds. But there is also an argument that MADD is a lobbying group more than a traditional charity with needy recipients, so it’s effectiveness, like it or not, is best measured in how well it passes legislation that meets its organizational goals.

And by most measures, they have been effectively, particularly in increasing the severity of ignition interlock requirements in different states nationwide.

But this new effort at enforcing drunk driving laws at the level of every vehicle on the road has many people concerned about civil liberties and privacy issues. There are countless issues raised by these systems.

  • How does due process work if everyone is a suspect?
  • What threshold alerts the system to stop the ignition from starting?
  • Who controls the data captured?
  • How accurate are the systems?
  • What if a passenger is drunk, and the driver is the responsible one? Can the environmental sensors tell the difference?

There is a considerable risk of any such data being used to incriminate people, or raise suspicion, even in cases when a person is within the law.

What if a person regularly drives with a level at .06 or .o7% BAC? Does the government capture that information? Can they use it to keep a close eye on anyone on the road known to drive with a couple of drinks in them?

This kind of road tracking surveillance data would be easy to use and implement with automatic license plate scanners in police cruisers, and access to this data.

The data mining and “big brother” possibilities of these systems need to be worked out well before any of these technologies hit the road, because unwinding them will be difficult to do.

Please Share!Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Reddit0Buffer this pageEmail this to someone

Filed Under: DWI Tagged With: breathalyser, DWI, MADD

Free Consultation

Contact our attorneys for a free legal case evaluation on any criminal charge by calling:

888-205-9314


Receive our free legal defense consultation and case evaluation. We'll explain what you are facing in plain language, and tell you how we can help.
Copyright © 2023 Get Lawyer Leads, Inc.
THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT. This is not a law firm or referral service and does not provide legal advice. This is a free matching service only, claim reviews will be performed by a third party attorney. An attorney-client relationship is not formed when you submit the form and you are under no obligation to retain a lawyer who contacts you through this service. Services are not available in all states.